Navigating Shame as a Narcissist: A Deep Dive into the Unseen Struggle

In a world where the phrase “you are being a narcissist” has become commonplace, I want to be clear that while some people may demonstrate features of narcissism, a narcissist demonstrates persistent features and multiple symptoms.  Please use this information to determine the difference between hurtful/harmful behaviors and considering someone a narcissist.

Understand Narcissistic Personality Disorder Better

Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) is a mental health condition characterized by an inflated sense of self-importance, a deep need for excessive admiration, and a lack of empathy for others. While confidence and ambition are normal traits, Narcissistic Personality Disorder takes these to an extreme and is contempt, criticism, and defensiveness driven, often causing significant challenges in relationships, work, and personal growth.

Key Symptoms of NPD

According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5), individuals with Narcissistic Personality Disorder may exhibit:

• Grandiosity, with exaggerated achievements or talents.

• A constant need for admiration and validation.

• A sense of entitlement, expecting special treatment.

• Difficulty handling criticism, often reacting with anger or defensiveness.

• A lack of empathy, disregarding others’ feelings or needs.

• Envy of others or a belief that others are envious of them.

These behaviors often mask a fragile self-esteem, making those with Narcissistic Personality Disorder highly sensitive to perceived slights and intolerable of shame or self consciousness.

Causes and Risk Factors

The exact cause of Narcissistic Personality Disorder is unclear as there are many disputes amongst professionals about genetic factors, but as of today we recognize that it likely stems from a mix of genetics, environment, and early life experiences. Overindulgent or overly critical parenting, trauma, or cultural influences that emphasize individualism may contribute. Narcissistic Personality Disorder typically emerges in adolescence or early adulthood and is diagnosed more frequently in men. In my opinion, the ease at which many biological women can experience attunement leads to perceived empathy and what other professionals have termed vulnerable narcissism, thus I’ve seen more covert narcissism in women. It is important to note that no single factor causes Narcissistic Personality Disorder; it typically results from an interplay of multiple factors. Not everyone with risk factors develops Narcissistic Personality Disorder, and protective factors (e.g., supportive relationships, resilience) can mitigate risk.  Please remember, diagnosis requires a professional evaluation, as narcissistic traits alone do not necessarily indicate Narcissistic Personality Disorder.

Causes:

1. Genetic Factors:

• There is evidence of a hereditary component, as NPD traits may run in families. Specific genes linked to personality traits like grandiosity or low empathy may increase susceptibility.

• Twin studies suggest a moderate genetic influence on narcissistic traits.

  2014 study by Livesley et al. (Journal of Personality Disorders)

2. Environmental Factors:

• Parenting Styles:

  • Excessive Pampering: Overindulgence or unrealistic praise from parents can foster an inflated sense of self.

  • Neglect or Criticism: Harsh, overly critical, or emotionally unavailable parenting may lead to compensatory grandiosity or attention-seeking behaviors.

    Diamond & Meehan (2013, Psychoanalytic Psychology) , Cramer (2011, Journal of Research in Personality), and Brummelman et al. (2015, PNAS)

• Cultural Influences:

  Societies that emphasize individualism, fame, or materialism may reinforce narcissistic traits.

  Twenge et al. (2008, Journal of Personality)& Cross-cultural studies (e.g., Foster et al., 2003, Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology) ; note that generalizability is difficult due to most research performed thus far focuses on Western culture. 

• Trauma or Abuse: 

  Early emotional, physical, or sexual abuse can contribute to maladaptive coping mechanisms, including narcissistic defenses.

  Boursier et al. (2020, Frontiers in Psychiatry)
  
  

3. Psychological Factors:

• Temperament: 

  Children with certain temperamental traits, like high sensitivity to criticism or a need for admiration, may be more prone to developing NPD.

• Defense Mechanisms: 

  Narcissistic traits may emerge as a way to protect a fragile self-esteem or mask feelings of inadequacy.

Risk Factors

• Family History: Having a parent or sibling with NPD or other personality disorders increases risk.

• Gender: NPD is diagnosed more frequently in males than females, though this may reflect diagnostic biases.

• Childhood Experiences:

  • Inconsistent parenting (e.g., alternating between neglect and over-praise).

  • Lack of secure attachment with caregivers.

• Personality Traits: High levels of traits like entitlement, low empathy, or need for control.

• Socioeconomic Factors: Growing up in environments that prioritize status, wealth, or appearance.

• Mental Health Conditions: Co-occurring conditions like anxiety, depression, or other personality disorders may amplify narcissistic traits.

Impact and Treatment

Narcissistic Personality Disorder can strain personal and professional relationships due to the individual’s self-centered behavior and difficulty with empathy. Many with Narcissistic Personality Disorder don’t seek help unless faced with secondary issues like depression, threats to lose jobs, or relationship breakdowns. Its impacts are wide-ranging, affecting individuals with NPD, their relationships, and their environments.  Here are some examples of Impact:

Impact on the individual

• Emotional and Psychological Challenges: People with NPD often experience fragile self-esteem, making them hypersensitive to criticism or failure. This can lead to intense emotional reactions, including anger, shame, or depression when their self-image is challenged.

• Interpersonal Difficulties: Their need for admiration and lack of empathy can strain relationships, leading to conflicts with family, friends, or colleagues. They may struggle to maintain long-term, meaningful connections.

• Career and Social Consequences: While some individuals with NPD may initially succeed in competitive or leadership roles due to their confidence, their arrogance, entitlement, or inability to handle criticism can lead to professional setbacks or social isolation.

• Co-occurring Issues: NPD is often associated with other mental health conditions, such as depression, anxiety, or substance use disorders, which can exacerbate distress and complicate functioning.

Impact on others

• Emotional Manipulation: Those close to someone with NPD may experience manipulation, gaslighting, or emotional abuse as the individual seeks to maintain control or admiration.

• Relationship Strain: Partners, family members, or friends may feel devalued, ignored, or exploited, leading to strained or broken relationships.

• Workplace Dynamics: In professional settings, colleagues or subordinates may face challenges due to the individual’s need for dominance, lack of collaboration, or dismissive behavior.  

Societal Impact

• Cultural Reinforcement: In cultures that emphasize individualism or celebrity, narcissistic traits may be amplified or normalized, potentially increasing the prevalence of NPD-like behaviors.

• Conflict and Division: On a broader scale, narcissistic tendencies in leaders or public figures can contribute to polarizing or self-serving decisions, affecting communities or organizations.

Treatment of NPD

Treating Narcissistic Personality Disorder is challenging because individuals with the disorder often lack insight into their condition and may resist seeking help due to their inflated self-image and shame intolerance. However, with motivation and professional intervention, progress is possible. See 5 considerations in treating narcissistic features:

1. Psychotherapy (Primary Treatment)

Psychotherapy is the cornerstone of Narcissistic Personality Disorder treatment, focusing on addressing maladaptive behaviors, improving self-awareness, and fostering healthier relationships.

• Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT):

  • Helps with emotion dysregulation, impulsivity, and interpersonal relationships
  • Encourages healthier lifestyle choices, improves communication, and supports empathy of others and emotional tolerance by recognizing that 2 opposites can exist simultaneously. 

• Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT):

  • Helps identify and modify distorted thought patterns, such as grandiose beliefs or hypersensitivity to criticism.
  • Encourages healthier coping mechanisms for handling setbacks or rejection.

• Schema Therapy:

  • Targets deep-rooted patterns (schemas) from childhood, such as feelings of inadequacy or entitlement, to address the root causes of narcissistic behaviors.

• Transference-Focused Psychotherapy (TFP):

  • Focuses on the therapeutic relationship to explore and address interpersonal dynamics, helping individuals understand how their behaviors affect others.

• Mentalization-Based Therapy (MBT):

  • Aims to improve the ability to understand one’s own and others’ mental states, fostering empathy and reducing self-centeredness.

• Group Therapy:

  • Provides a setting to practice interpersonal skills and receive feedback, though it may be challenging for individuals with NPD due to their sensitivity to criticism.

• Trauma Focused Therapy

• • Focuses on healing attachment wounds and traumatic experiences that may reinforce symptoms and features of narcissism 

  • Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) - works by helping the brain process and integrate the distressing memories, reducing their impact and allowing for more adaptive responses

  • Deep Brain Reorienting (DBR) - aims to reorient the brain's response to trauma, facilitating healing and reducing the intensity of traumatic memories and related symptoms giving individuals new perspectives on self, others, and/or experiences.

2. Addressing Co-occuring Conditions

• Medication: No specific medication treats Narcissistic Personality Disorder, but medications like antidepressants or anti-anxiety drugs may be prescribed to manage co-occurring conditions such as depression or anxiety.

• Substance Abuse Treatment: If substance use is present, integrated treatment for addiction is critical.

3. Challenges in Treatment

• Resistance to Therapy: Individuals with Narcissistic Personality Disorder may view therapy as unnecessary or feel criticized, leading to dropout or lack of engagement.

• Therapist-Patient Dynamics: Therapists must navigate the patient’s grandiosity or defensiveness carefully to build trust.

• Long-Term Commitment: Progress is often slow, requiring sustained effort over years.

4. Strategies to Improve Outcomes

• Motivation for Change: Treatment is more effective when individuals recognize the negative consequences of their behavior (e.g., relationship breakdowns or career issues) and are motivated to change.

• Building Empathy: Therapies that focus on perspective-taking can help develop empathy, a key deficit in Narcissistic Personality Disorder.

• Support for Loved Ones: Family therapy or support groups for partners and family members can help them cope with the individual’s behavior and set healthy boundaries.

5. Self Help and Lifestyle Changes

While self-help alone is insufficient, individuals can benefit from:

• Practicing mindfulness to increase self-awareness.

• Seeking feedback from trusted individuals to understand their impact on others.

• Engaging in activities that promote humility, such as volunteering.

• Managing your own health and sleep to support emotional regulation

Supporting Someone with Narcissistic Personality Disorder (applies to the therapist as well)

If you’re working with or have any kind of connection to someone with Narcissistic Personality Disorder, setting boundaries and practicing self-care are crucial. Encourage professional help without judgment, as confrontation can escalate defensiveness. Understanding that their behavior often stems from insecurity can foster compassion while protecting your well-being.

Prognosis

• Variable Outcomes: Some individuals with NPD can achieve significant improvement with consistent therapy, particularly if they develop insight and motivation. Others may struggle to change due to entrenched patterns.

• Factors for Success: Younger age, milder symptoms, and a willingness to engage in therapy are associated with better outcomes.

• Ongoing Management: Even with progress, individuals may need long-term support to maintain healthier behaviors and relationships.

Conclusion

Narcissistic Personality Disorder is complex, blending grandiosity with vulnerability. While it poses challenges, awareness and professional support can pave the way for healthier interactions and personal growth. If you suspect Narcissistic Personality Disorder in yourself or someone else, consulting a mental health professional is the first step toward understanding and managing the condition. As a treating professional (LCSW, LPC, psychiatrist, etc) it is important to engage in consultation with other clinicians, regularly, as the professional treating those exhibiting narcissism and individuals recovering from narcissistic abuse to ensure management of your own boundaries, meeting care standards for your profession, and provision of quality care. 

Want to learn more check our series.